Insights
What does family legal recognition look like?
Region(s)
Type
Commentary
Author(s)
Publish Date
Share
What makes a family? Love, care, support, and a sense of belonging—a shared identity that binds people together. But what happens when your family isn’t legally recognized? That love and care can get tangled in legal red tape—impacting things like inheritance, shared property, parental rights, and even access to healthcare decisions.
Discrimination based on who you love or how you define your family creates unnecessary barriers. It’s unfair, outdated, and harms individuals and communities. Achieving legal recognition for all families is about more than paperwork—it’s about dignity, equality, and ensuring no one is left behind. When families of all kinds are recognized and respected, everyone benefits: children, their guardians, committed couples, single parents, and society at large.
To fully recognize diverse families, it’s crucial to focus on the legal protections that ensure their rights. Let's dive into the specifics of what inclusive family recognition should encompass.
1. Recognition of same-sex parenthood and parental rights
Laws should establish equitable parenthood recognition for same-sex partners with children. Same-sex partners should not have to jump through any more hoops than different-sex partners to ensure their children receive the protections provided to those in heterosexual families. This includes equal rights and responsibilities for both parents in decision-making, custody arrangements, and legal recognition, regardless of biological ties. Simplifying these processes promotes equality and stability for all families.
Example: Claudia and Mary, a same-sex couple, have been raising their daughter, Sofia, together since her birth. However, only Claudia, the biological mother, is legally recognized as a parent. When the couple separates, Mary loses access to Sofia because she has no legal rights as her parent. Despite being an active and loving parent throughout Sofia’s life, Mary is excluded from making decisions or even maintaining a relationship with her daughter, causing emotional harm to both.
2. Protection of shared property and inheritance rights
Same-sex partners must have equal rights to shared property and inheritance. Laws should provide for joint ownership of assets acquired during relationships and ensure that a surviving partner inherits shared property without complex legal procedures. Comprehensive protections affirm the financial stability of same-sex partners and prevent legal disputes among family members.
Example: For 20 years, John and Miguel shared a home, purchased in John’s name, and all household expenses. When Miguel passes away unexpectedly, his siblings claim ownership of the house because there are no clear legal protections for same-sex couples. Without laws ensuring shared property and inheritance rights, surviving partners risk losing their homes or facing costly legal battles.
3. Recognition of marriages, civil unions, and domestic partnerships
Marriages, civil unions, and domestic partnerships should provide equal rights to same-sex and different-sex couples. This includes spousal privileges, hospital visitation rights, healthcare decision-making, and access to benefits. Equal recognition ensures that families are protected in legal and institutional contexts, regardless of where their union was established.
Example: Marcus and Terrence, a married same-sex couple, relocate to a country where their marriage isn’t recognized. When Marcus gets into a serious car accident, Terrence is denied access to visit him in the hospital because he isn’t considered a legal spouse. Without recognition of their marriage, Terrence is excluded from critical moments and decisions, highlighting the profound impact of inconsistent legal protections on families.
4. Protection against family violence
Laws aimed at eradicating domestic violence, intimate partner violence, and other forms of family violence must explicitly include same-sex partners and their children, ensuring equal access to restraining orders, shelters, and counseling. Authorities should be trained to recognize and address violence in all family types, breaking barriers created by stigma or exclusion.
Example: Jamila is in an abusive relationship with her same-sex partner, but when she seeks a restraining order, local authorities dismiss her case because they don’t recognize domestic violence in same-sex relationships. Without inclusive laws and properly trained authorities, victims face barriers in accessing protection and justice.
5. Equal access to social and employment benefits
Families in all forms must have access to social security benefits, health insurance, and parental leave without discrimination. Employers and service providers should extend these benefits to same-sex partners and their children, ensuring fair treatment and financial security.
Example: Danielle works at a company that offers family health insurance, but her same-sex partner, Alicia, is excluded from coverage due to discriminatory policies. This forces Alicia, who has a modest income, to pay for expensive private healthcare. The lack of equitable access to workplace benefits creates financial strain and undermines the stability of their family.
6. Nationality and immigration rights for diverse families
Immigration and nationality laws must recognize same-sex partners and their children, enabling family reunification and protection across borders. Families should retain their legal rights when moving internationally, avoiding separation or loss of protections due to differing national laws.
Example: Julien and Wei, a binational same-sex couple, want to build their life together in a new country. However, because their relationship isn’t legally recognized, Julien can only stay on a temporary tourist visa, which doesn’t allow him to live, work, or access long-term stability. This forces them to endure repeated separations or live in constant uncertainty, unable to settle as a family. Restrictive immigration laws deny them the rights and protections that other married couples take for granted.
7. Representation of diverse families in education
Schools play a key role in reducing stigma and fostering acceptance. Curricula should reflect diverse family structures, and anti-discrimination laws must protect children and parents from diverse families in educational settings, healthcare, and public services.
Example: The son of Noura and Paula is bullied at school because his classmates don’t understand what it means to have two moms, and the school staff fails to intervene due to a lack of training on family diversity. The absence of representation and clear policies perpetuates stigma and harms the well-being of children from diverse families.
8. Access to reproductive technologies and fertility preservation
Equitable access to reproductive technologies, such as in vitro fertilization (IVF) and surrogacy, must be ensured for same-sex partners, trans individuals, and single parents. Fertility preservation options, like egg or sperm freezing, should also be accessible and affordable, including for individuals planning to undergo gender-affirming treatments that may impact reproductive potential.
Example: Alex, a trans man, and his partner, Ethan, dream of starting a family. However, when Alex seeks to preserve his eggs before beginning gender-affirming hormone therapy, he is met with high costs and a lack of supportive medical providers who understand his needs. The couple also struggles to access IVF due to discriminatory policies that exclude same-sex couples and trans individuals. These barriers not only delay their plans for parenthood but also create unnecessary emotional and financial stress.
9. Recognition of gender identity in family documents
Family-related legal documents, such as birth certificates and custody agreements, must accurately reflect the gender identity of trans individuals. Simplifying the process for updating these documents protects the rights of trans parents and prevents complications in their daily lives.
Example: Amina, a trans woman, is listed as "father" on her child's birth certificate, even though she has legally changed her name and gender marker. Every time she presents the document—for school applications or healthcare purposes—she faces uncomfortable questions and even discrimination because it does not align with her gender identity. Ensuring that family documents accurately reflect Amina’s gender identity would affirm her rights and simplify her interactions with institutions.
10. Cross-border family protections
Families formed across borders face unique challenges due to varying legal systems. Governments must recognize family rights established in other jurisdictions, ensuring that legal protections for parenthood, custody, and family structures are preserved internationally.
Example: Aisha and Claire, a married couple, had twins through IVF, with Claire as the biological mother. When they move to a new country for work, the local laws don’t recognize their marriage or Aisha’s parental rights. This means Aisha cannot enroll the twins in school, make medical decisions for them, or secure residency as their legal parent. The lack of cross-border family protections creates legal and emotional challenges, forcing families like theirs to navigate uncertain and unfair systems.
Take Action
When you support our research, you support a growing global movement and celebrate LGBTIQ lives everywhere.
Donate Now